| Pick | Round 1 | Round 2 | Round 3 | Round 4 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Wildhacks Kyle Boller | Wildhacks Chris Brown | Wildhacks Justin Fargas | Wildhacks |
| 2 | ANTEbob Byron Leftwich | Schlomos Taylor Jacobs | ANTEbob Najeh Davenport | ANTEbob Chester Taylor |
| 3 | Shanahans Charles Rogers | Sludgekats Bill Schroeder | Sludgekats | Sludgekats |
| 4 | Toilet Andre Johnson | Toilet Adrian Peterson | Toilet | Toilet |
| 5 | Eat-ums Willis McGahee | Eat-ums Kevin Curtis | Eat-ums | Eat-ums |
| 6 | Cowboys Kelly Holcomb | Cowboys Thomas Jones | Cowboys Seth Marler | Cowboys |
| 7 | Non-Seqs Onterrio Smith | Non-Seqs Chris Simms | Army Josh Brown | Non-Seqs |
| 8 | Army Carson Palmer | Shanahans Tyrone Calico | Army | Army |
| 9 | Asylum Rodney Peete | Asylum Lamar Gordon | Asylum | Asylum |
| 10 | Schlomos LaBrandon Toefield | Schlomos Musa Smith | Schlomos | Schlomos |
| 11 | Knowledge Trung Canidate | Moscow Drew Henson | Knowledge Jake Delhomme | Konnichiwa Vinny Testaverde |
| 12 | Konnichiwa Kelley Washington | Moscow Ladell Betts | Moscow Steve Smith | Moscow |
| 13 | Army Larry Johnson | Shanahans Aaron Elling | Shanahans | Konnichiwa |
| 14 | Konnichiwa Tony Hollings | Konnichiwa Kevin Faulk | Konnichiwa Shayne Graham | Knowledge |
| 15 | Conspiracies Bryant Johnson | Eat-ums Doug Johnson | Shanahans | Konnichiwa |
| 16 | Friendship Marc Boerigter | Friendship Rex Grossman | Friendship Quentin Griffin | Friendship |