| Pick | Round 1 | Round 2 | Round 3 | Round 4 | Round 5 | Round 6 | Round 7 | Round 8 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Shanahans William Green | Shanahans Josh Reed | Shanahans Billy Cundiff | Shanahans Bears ST | Shanahans | Shanahans | Shanahans | Shanahans |
| 2 | Wildhacks DeShaun Foster | Wildhacks Ashley Lelie | Wildhacks Ravens ST | Wildhacks | Wildhacks | Wildhacks | Wildhacks | Wildhacks |
| 3 | Schlomos T.J. Duckett | Toilet D'Wayne Bates | Schlomos Buccaneers ST | Schlomos Marquise Walker | Schlomos Brian Westbrook | Schlomos Neil Rackers | Schlomos | Schlomos |
| 4 | Schlomos David Carr | Toilet Chad Hutchinson | Toilet Steve Christie | Toilet Raiders ST | Toilet | Toilet | Toilet | Toilet |
| 5 | Friendship Clinton Portis | Friendship Donald Driver | Friendship Derrius Thompson | Friendship Giants ST | Friendship | Friendship | Friendship | Friendship |
| 6 | Cowboys Joey Harrington | Cowboys Az-Zahir Hakim | Cowboys Chad Lewis | Cowboys Owen Pochman | Cowboys Chiefs D | Cowboys Jeff Blake | Cowboys MarTay Jenkins | Cowboys David Sloan |
| 7 | Eat-ums Antonio Bryant | Army Reche Caldwell | Army | Army | Army | Army | Army | Army |
| 8 | Conspiracies Patrick Ramsey | Eat-ums Hayden Epstein | Conspiracies Andre Davis | Conspiracies Lions ST | Conspiracies | Conspiracies | Conspiracies | Conspiracies |
| 9 | Sludgekats Jonathan Wells | Army Browns D | Sludgekats Bob Christian | Sludgekats Robert Ferguson | Sludgekats Jon Kitna | Sludgekats Texans D | Sludgekats | Sludgekats |
| 10 | ANTEbob Jeremy Shockey | ANTEbob Zack Crockett | ANTEbob Packers D | ANTEbob Doug Brien | ANTEbob | ANTEbob | ANTEbob | ANTEbob |
| 11 | Moscow Amos Zereoue | Moscow Corey Bradford | Moscow Patriots ST | Moscow | Moscow | Moscow | Moscow | Moscow |
| 12 | Eat-ums Antwaan Randle El | Eat-ums Steve Beuerlein | Eat-ums Eagles ST | Eat-ums | Eat-ums | Eat-ums | Eat-ums | Eat-ums |
| 13 | Asylum Danny Wuerffel | Asylum Texans ST | Asylum Jerome Pathon | Asylum | Asylum | Asylum | Asylum | Asylum |
| 14 | ANTEbob Donte' Stallworth | Knowledge Brian Finneran | Knowledge Rodney Peete | Knowledge 49ers ST | Knowledge | Knowledge | Knowledge | Knowledge |
| 15 | Konnichiwa Jabar Gaffney | Non-Seqs David Garrard | Knowledge Shyrone Stith | Knowledge Jamel White | Non-Seqs | Konnichiwa Chad Johnson | Konnichiwa Jaguars ST | Konnichiwa |
| 16 | Non-Seqs Javon Walker | Sludgekats Gus Frerotte | Non-Seqs Bills ST | Non-Seqs | Non-Seqs | Non-Seqs | Non-Seqs | Non-Seqs |