| Pick | Round 1 | Round 2 | Round 3 | Round 4 | Round 5 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Eat-ums LaDainian Tomlinson | Conspiracies Rod Gardner | Conspiracies Chris Chambers | Conspiracies Ryan Leaf | Conspiracies John Kasay |
| 2 | Shanahans Michael Bennett | Shanahans Freddie Mitchell | Shanahans Mike McMahon | Shanahans | Shanahans |
| 3 | Konnichiwa Michael Vick | Non-Seqs Doug Flutie | Knowledge Jamel White | Konnichiwa | Konnichiwa |
| 4 | Shanahans Travis Henry | Friendship Willie Jackson | Friendship Todd Pinkston | Friendship Jay Feely | Friendship Sage Rosenfels |
| 5 | Army Drew Brees | Army Reggie Wayne | Army LaMont Jordan | Army Rudi Johnson | Army |
| 6 | Shanahans Koren Robinson | Konnichiwa Marvin Minnis | Schlomos Joe Jurevicius | Schlomos | Schlomos |
| 7 | Sludgekats Terry Allen | Sludgekats Jeff George | Sludgekats Raghib Ismail | Sludgekats Rian Lindell | Sludgekats |
| 8 | Moscow James Jackson | Moscow Jeff Blake | Moscow Justin McCareins | Moscow | Moscow |
| 9 | Wildhacks Chris Weinke | Wildhacks Bill Gramatica | Wildhacks Robert Ferguson | Wildhacks | Wildhacks |
| 10 | Cowboys David Terrell | Cowboys Tommy Maddox | Cowboys | Cowboys | Cowboys |
| 11 | Conspiracies Deuce McAllister | Eat-ums Marques Tuiasosopo | Eat-ums Nick Goings | Conspiracies Saints ST | Conspiracies 49ers D |
| 12 | ANTEbob Kevan Barlow | ANTEbob Quincy Morgan | Sludgekats Richie Anderson | ANTEbob Tony Richardson | ANTEbob |
| 13 | Konnichiwa Santana Moss | Konnichiwa Chad Johnson | Sludgekats Brandon Stokley | Non-Seqs | Non-Seqs |
| 14 | Asylum J.J. Stokes | Asylum Bill Schroeder | Asylum | Asylum | Asylum |
| 15 | Toilet Quincy Carter | Toilet Jason Brookins | Toilet Correll Buckhalter | Toilet | Toilet |
| 16 | Non-Seqs Anthony Thomas | Toilet Jose Cortez | Konnichiwa Freddie Jones | Knowledge | Knowledge |