| Pick | Round 1 | Round 2 | Round 3 | Round 4 | Round 5 | Round 6 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Conspiracies Ron Dayne | Wildhacks Chris Redman | ANTEbob Robert Chancey | ANTEbob David Akers | Non-Seqs | Non-Seqs |
| 2 | Wildhacks Thomas Jones | Wildhacks Reuben Droughns | Wildhacks | Wildhacks | Wildhacks | Wildhacks |
| 3 | Knowledge Peter Warrick | Toilet Sylvester Morris | Knowledge Joe Hamilton | Non-Seqs | Knowledge | Knowledge |
| 4 | Army Plaxico Burress | Army Bubba Franks | Army | Army | Army | Army |
| 5 | Shanahans Jamal Lewis | Shanahans Jim Kleinsasser | Shanahans | Shanahans | Shanahans | Shanahans |
| 6 | Konnichiwa Shaun Alexander | Konnichiwa Dennis Northcutt | Knowledge | Konnichiwa Tee Martin | Konnichiwa | Konnichiwa |
| 7 | Eat-ums Laveranues Coles | Eat-ums Jerry Porter | Eat-ums Trung Canidate | Eat-ums | Eat-ums | Eat-ums |
| 8 | Sludgekats Fred Beasley | Sludgekats Sebastian Janikowski | Sludgekats Mike Cloud | Sludgekats Shawn Jefferson | Sludgekats Brad Daluiso | Sludgekats Frank Wycheck |
| 9 | Schlomos Chad Pennington | ANTEbob Terry Jackson | Moscow R. Jay Soward | Friendship | ANTEbob | ANTEbob |
| 10 | Friendship Tiki Barber | Friendship James Allen | Friendship Eagles D | Friendship | Friendship | Friendship |
| 11 | Knowledge Travis Taylor | Toilet Ron Dugans | Toilet Tim Seder | Toilet Oronde Gadsden | Toilet | Toilet |
| 12 | Asylum Lamar Smith | Asylum Kent Graham | Asylum | Asylum | Asylum | Asylum |
| 13 | Conspiracies J.R. Redmond | Schlomos Anthony Becht | Schlomos | Schlomos | Schlomos | Schlomos |
| 14 | Cowboys Jermaine Fazande | Cowboys Giovanni Carmazzi | Cowboys Marty Booker | Cowboys | Cowboys | Cowboys |
| 15 | ANTEbob Travis Prentice | Moscow Darrell Jackson | Moscow | Moscow | Moscow | Moscow |
| 16 | Non-Seqs Jay Fiedler | Schlomos Neil Rackers | Conspiracies | Conspiracies | Conspiracies | Conspiracies |